The multifamily market has changed, and some of the strategies that made investors money for years are harder to execute. Value-add investing has lost some of its luster, prompting Janet LePage, co-founder and CEO of Western Wealth Capital, to shift her focus toward a new opportunity.
In our recent conversation, Janet hinted at this largely overlooked strategy. For years, she has been using the traditional value-add strategy to buy multifamily properties at a lower cost basis and increase rents. But due to higher interest rates and oversupply in many markets, she’s adding another “pillar” to her portfolio.
In five years, low-income housing tax credits (LIHTC) will start expiring on a wave of apartment buildings, allowing operators to bring discounted rents up to market rates. Many developers who made their money on the front end are now looking to sell these properties, and Janet wants to be first in line.
Western Wealth Capital has already acquired over 1,000 of these units and plans to grow that part of their portfolio up to 5,000 units before these assets are done changing hands. Today, Janet shares the investment thesis behind the pivot and how other investors can take advantage of this five-year window.
Insights from today’s episode:
- Janet’s low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) investing model explained
- The major headwinds working against traditional value-add multifamily investing
- Why a large wave of LIHTC properties is approaching expiration in the next five years
- How to use the LIHTC model to capture built-in rent growth potential
- Compliance issues to consider when doing your due diligence on LIHTC properties
—
Episode 1011 – Scaling to 30,000+ Multifamily Units with a “Win-Win” Strategy w/Janet LePage
Connect with Janet on LinkedIn
Recommended Resources:
- If you’re a high-net-worth investor with capital to deploy in the next 12 months and you want to build passive income and wealth with a trusted partner, click here for opportunities to invest in real estate projects alongside Kevin and his team.
- Accredited Investors, you’re invited to Join the Cash Flow Investor Club to learn how you can partner with Kevin Bupp on current and upcoming opportunities to create passive cash flow and build wealth. Join the Club!
- Looking for the ultimate guide to passive investing? Grab a copy of my latest book, The Cash Flow Investor at KevinBupp.com.
- Tap into a wealth of free information on Commercial Real Estate Investing by listening to past podcast episodes at KevinBupp.com/Podcast.
This podcast is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Consult with a qualified professional before making any investment decisions.
Chapters:
00:00 Intro
02:18 Low-Income Housing Tax Credit
03:56 What Happened to Value-Add?
09:07 How the LIHTC Program Works
14:55 The Typical Buy Box
23:24 Janet’s Recent Acquisitions
30:06 Expertise & Due Diligence
35:34 Operational Differences
42:32 The 5-Year “Runway”
46:47 How to Start Today
50:34 Connect with Janet!
Episode Transcript
Episode Summary
In this episode of the Real Estate Investing for Cash Flow podcast, Kevin Bupp welcomes back Janet LePage, co-founder and CEO of Western Wealth Capital, for a deeper look at her move into low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) multifamily. Janet explains why traditional value-add investing is on pause, as new supply and higher interest rates have narrowed the gap between renovated and brand-new units, and why expiring LIHTC properties can offer a similar loss-to-lease opportunity. She breaks down how the program works, why the next five years bring five to ten times the usual number of expirations, and what belongs in her buy box, from the delta to market rent to local supply and operations. Janet walks through two recent Chattanooga acquisitions bought at roughly $115,000 a unit, about $100,000 below new construction. The conversation also covers due diligence and compliance, the role of housing authorities, extended-use and first-right-of-sale clauses, local property management, tenant protections, and agency financing perks. Janet closes with why her team does not develop, her goal of three to five thousand LIHTC units, regulatory risk, and why longer-dated assets with higher yields suit evergreen funds and family offices. Throughout, Janet stresses staying in your lane, building repeatable systems, and treating the strategy as an operating business rather than a financial trick.
Key Takeaways
– Value-add is on pause, not dead. New supply from 2021 on, concessions, and higher interest rates have shrunk what renters will pay for a renovated unit, so Western Wealth Capital is leaning toward expiring LIHTC while value-add waits.
– Expiring LIHTC works like loss-to-lease. Rents on these properties often sit 25 to 30 percent below market and can reset to market when restrictions end, and the next five years bring far more expirations than the usual 10,000 units a year.
– The delta to market rent is the first buy box check. Janet also screens for limited new LIHTC competition, operators who are not focused on operations, small assets that can be bundled, and capex she can budget.
– Compliance and local expertise decide the deal. Read every document for extended-use periods and first-right-of-sale terms, build a relationship with the local housing authority, and use local consultants or property managers at the start.
– Longer-dated LIHTC is a yield play. Assets with nine or more years left can trade at 7.5 to 8 percent cap rates with cash flow growing toward 14 percent, which suits evergreen funds and family offices.
Key Topics Covered
– Low-income housing tax credit (LIHTC) basics and expirations
– Why traditional value-add multifamily is on pause
– The LIHTC buy box: delta to market rent, supply, operations, vintage, and capex
– Two Chattanooga acquisitions and basis versus new construction
– Due diligence, compliance, and housing authority approvals
– Extended-use periods and first-right-of-sale clauses
– Property management, leasing, and tenant protections on LIHTC assets
– Agency financing benefits and prepayment flexibility
– Regulatory risk and the five-year window of opportunity
– Longer-dated LIHTC assets as a yield play
Episode Chapters
00:00 Intro
Kevin opens with a real example: units bought at about $115,000, roughly $100,000 below new construction, and introduces Janet LePage for the actual LIHTC playbook.
02:18 Low-Income Housing Tax Credit
Janet gives a snapshot of Western Wealth Capital, which has bought more than 29,000 units and about 1,000 LIHTC units, and why LIHTC is a forward-looking part of her investment thesis.
03:56 What Happened to Value-Add?
Janet explains why value-add is paused, with new supply, rent concessions, and higher rates narrowing the premium for renovated units, and when she expects it to make sense again.
09:07 How the LIHTC Program Works
Janet breaks down how states award credits for rent-capped buildings, the 30-year compliance terms, why expirations are set to jump over the next five years, and why occupancy and turnover look so strong.
14:55 The Typical Buy Box
Janet walks through the buy box: the delta to market rent, limited new LIHTC supply, operators who have moved on to the next deal, smaller bundled assets, and how she views vintage and capex.
23:24 Janet’s Recent Acquisitions
Janet details two recent Chattanooga acquisitions, why the basis sits well below new construction and neighboring market-rate buildings, and why sellers sometimes sell before expiration.
30:06 Expertise & Due Diligence
Kevin and Janet cover the team needed for LIHTC due diligence, the housing authority’s role, expiration gotchas such as extended-use periods and first right of sale, and why the documents intimidate buyers.
35:34 Operational Differences
Janet explains why she brings in a local property manager at first, how housing authority inspections slow leasing, how waitlists help, what eviction rules look like, and what agency financing offers.
42:32 The 5-Year “Runway”
Janet explains why her team does not develop, her goal of three to five thousand LIHTC units, the surge in expiring volume, and the regulatory risk of buying in heavily social-focused states.
46:47 How to Start Today
Janet tells experienced operators to master the compliance rules first, then shares how longer-dated assets with nine or more years remaining can be a high-yield play for long-term capital.
50:34 Connect with Janet!
Kevin wraps the conversation and Janet points listeners to westernwealthcapital.com.
Full Transcript
Janet LePage: What we paid, you’re looking at about $115,000 a unit. These are 2005 to 2010 vintage. Market rate for these exact same things, like I’m talking right next door, if they were market rate, they would be $190 a door. and new construction about 220 a door. So if you just take a step back, we’re buying something $100,000 below new construction and basically $65,000 below the building right next door. We don’t have to increase the rent, we don’t have to do anything else. You’re buying the exact same unit. So when you’re talking about a basis value play, it’s incredible.
Kevin Bupp: What if the part of a real estate deal that scares most buyers away is actually where the opportunity comes from? Welcome to the Real Estate Investing for Cashflow podcast. I’m Kevin Bupp. About a month ago, I had Janet LePage of Western Wealth Capital on the show. She has had an impressive journey in real estate. And toward the end of that conversation, we started to cover a newer area of focus within multifamily that I really wanted to understand more about. So I’ve invited Janet back onto the show. This time around though, we’re going to get into the actual playbook. What makes one of these LIHTC deals worth pursuing?
How cheap prices the gap between restricted and market rents? Where compliance can completely change the investment? And what really happens as those restrictions move toward expiration? There’s a lot here for anyone who owns apartments or just simply wants to understand how experienced operators find opportunity when the traditional playbook stops working. Let’s get into it. So Janet, happy to have you back here. And we had a conversation not too long ago. And in that first conversation, we spent a lot of time talking about you scaling a pretty significant business in market-rated apartments. And then ultimately the second half, or maybe the latter half of the conversation, we talked quite a bit about your move into income-restricted multifamily.
We talked a little bit about why it caught your attention recently. I think we really only kind of scratched the surface on it all. So today, I’d really love to get under the hood with you, really understand what makes a deal work, what can go wrong, and what it takes to grow this into a meaningful business. And so I guess really to kick this off, before we get into the playbook and the nitty-gritty stuff, Maybe if you would, just give us a snapshot of your business today. How many LIHTC properties or units do you own? I know you’ve got a few that are under contract in different stages of due diligence.
And then maybe a little bit about your pipeline as well. How many of these are you seeing on an ongoing basis?
Janet LePage: Sure. Absolutely. Thanks for having me again, Kevin. It’s good to see you. Yeah, excited. Excited for this conversation. We’re going to get into the details. I’m CEO co-founder. We’ve purchased over 29,000 apartment multifamily units. As a female founder, I’ve actually bought the most number of units in the history of the U.S. So that’s something I’m really proud of. Yeah. And but we’re not talking about that today. We’re talking about what we call low income tax credit housing or what the acronym is, is LIHTC. And so it’s a strategy that is part of our entire investment thesis. We’ve been, you know, historically really well known for value add workforce multifamily across the Sunbelt.
That’s our our key parts within the LIHTC space. We’ve really kicked this off in the last year and a half and just showing just over a thousand units. So out of our 30,000 that we purchased, this is a forward looking strategy and one that we shifted into, which I think we should get into kind of why and the components, because I think that’s a really key part of the thesis as a forward going in this time of a market cycle. So that’s kind of where we’re at and where we’re looking to go forward.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, well, maybe let’s unpack that real quick. I know we talked about that briefly on our first conversation. Just obviously the traditional value-add multifamily space, it’s difficult today. The model that worked five years ago, it doesn’t necessarily work today. There’s a multitude of challenges within that space. So maybe unpack that for us a little bit, and that will help us transition and understand the pivot. And it’s not an entire pivot. You’re not getting away from multifamily or even traditional multifamily. If it worked today, you would be putting all your eggs and putting a lot of focus in that basket. But we know the times have changed.
So maybe unpack that for us a little bit. And again, that will help add context and us all better understand this maybe temporary transition or slight transition or slight pivot into the LIHTC deals.
Janet LePage: I think it’s more of an and versus an or, right?
Kevin Bupp: Yes, an and. That’s a good point.
Janet LePage: As you grow, it’s an and that when you have many ands, you sort of lean on different levers of your ands depending on where the cycle is. So I’ll go to really what we’re most known for and call it back in historical history. really it was to move into an asset that had been mismanaged or just not managed, had a number of classic units. Our average vintage was 1980s. You’d be able to go in, do a renovation, and really double our investors’ equity by doing the most basic things of cabinets, flooring, appliances, quick in and out, and that would move your rents, you know, 20% or so.
And really just in that basic program, you would double your investors’ equity. That is a classic historical value add. At the peak of our buying cycle, we were buying an apartment building every 12 and a half days. What we were known for, what we are known for, is a system. a system that basically can identify what is the sandbox that makes sense and then implementing it. And so that’s a foundational part of really what Western Wealth Capital is, is, you know, repeatability creates scalability. And with each of those facets, you know, you start with your macroeconomic environment. You’ve got in-migration. So there’s job creation. There’s lack of housing.
That’s your macro. What is the workforce there? So often people ask like, oh, are you buying in San Francisco or are you buying in these certain metro cities? And I go, well, no. When you’re buying, you want to align what the job, you know, what your job profile is to where people are living. Like those are really critical things. It’s not about being the fanciest. It’s about meeting people where they’re at. Yeah.
Kevin Bupp: So, you know, that strategy is a little bit on pause right now. Why is value add on pause right now across the U.S.?
Janet LePage: Very simple. We saw a huge amount of supply come on from 2021, 2022, really through to now due to low interest rates that was able to enable a lot of building. And so as that’s being absorbed in all of these major cities, that’s a lot competing with the. other units. So they have to fill these units with residents. And so they’re giving discounts to those rents. And suddenly someone’s not willing to pay the $200 or $300 more for a renovated unit when they can get almost the exact same brand new unit. And that absorption has been on top of the interest rate increases that we’ve seen.
So over these last few years and navigating that. And so Value-add doesn’t make sense right now. When will it make sense again is probably one of those questions you asked. It’s when absorption stops, right? And when the delta between the brand new and the next level of asset comes. And we’re seeing that now with the interest rates high. In many cases, the absorption is outpacing the demand. And we’re really going to get into an You probably have a good year or so because the people that moved into the new assets have to cycle through that, you know, that lower rent. And then they’re going to increase the rent and you say, I can’t afford that.
And so, you know, you’re looking at a couple of years. And when that has been our investment thesis. and it doesn’t make sense, you start to raise your head and look at other investment theses that do make sense at this time. And that’s really where we started to do a big focus on purchasing LIHTC assets that will have future expirations.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, no, that’s great. I appreciate the additional context. I think that’s very helpful for those that are maybe not… entirely familiar with what’s really changed here the last couple of years with the traditional value-add model and market rate apartments. And so what I would love to know, I think you’ll correct me if I’m wrong, I think you had referenced that roughly about 1,000 of the doors that your company currently owns today, 1,000 of those are Li-Tech deals. And I guess – What have you learned from the first number of deals? I mean, I’m sure like the first one’s always kind of like the or the first couple are like the case study, right?
Trying to prove your investment thesis, right? It’s all theoretical until you can actually put it into practice, put it into action. And so what have any big takeaways from the first couple of deals and ultimately anything that’s changed how you’ve looked at future deals?
Janet LePage: So one of the things is historically, even in the 130 apartment buildings that we have owned, there have been apartment buildings that we’ve owned that would have a component of it. So it was something that we were actually very familiar with. It just wasn’t our investment thesis, which I need to really get into what does it mean with expiring LIHTC. Right. And why does that look actually quite similar to value-add multifamily? And so I think I need to go back to sort of that basic piece. So over the number of years in the almost 30,000 partner units we built, we did have experience managing it.
It wasn’t our primary profit driver, if you will, from an investment partner. So Talking about low-income tax credit housing, what it is is there are credits that the state offers to developers to basically say to build a building that would have rents capped at a certain amount. It could be 30% of AMI. It could be 50%. There’s sort of a formula when you’re going through that. And what that means is they give a credit so that that’s the affordable housing. It is privately owned. But with it becomes terms. And many of those terms say that they have to stay with this compliance or this, you know, reduced rent on a certain number or 100% of those units for 30 years.
If we go back 25 years from now, there was a big influx of a building. So on average in the U.S., you’re looking at about only 10,000 units a year that expire with a LIHTC. What does that mean? It allows the property, unless you put it into a new program, to actually move to market rent. So if you average these buildings, you’re looking at an asset that could have 25 to 30% of the rents below market rent. Okay. When it expires, it then can move them to market rent, which is very similar to a value-add asset or what many of us would call loss to lease.
What could that rent go for? And so what you’re seeing now in the next five years of expiring is about 10 times higher. you know, five to 10 times depending on the year, the number of expiring units. So when you’re looking at the thesis, one of the things is it’s not a new concept. What’s different right now in the next five years is it’ll be the biggest volume of expiration that we’ve experienced yet in the U.S.
Kevin Bupp: Is it safe to say that as the expiration term comes near, that these become more in the radar of traditional apartment buyers, right? Knowing that they just have to wait it out one year, two year, three years. And so they might pay a premium than that of maybe a property that’s got seven, eight, nine, ten years remaining on the restrictions.
Janet LePage: Right. Absolutely. The one thing I would say is every year you get closer, absolutely the value, because basically what people are seeing or buying is a proven, you know, loss to lease or a delta in the rent. Once it expires, that value even goes more because there is compliance, there’s paperwork, there’s rules you need to follow. with leasing to tenants that many market rate deals, all market rate deals don’t have to follow. So if you’re a buyer, you know, you can shy away from that. We’re a perfect example. If you go back through our history, we were able to make, you know, that was our investment thesis was value add.
If there was a bunch of compliance on top with a huge number of LIHTC units, because not all the 100% of the building could be that. It could be 80, it could be 30%. You know, those assets we didn’t necessarily chase because it was just another layer of compliance work that you would need to do. And that allows you, the longer you go back, the more the, you know, the greater the cap rate. It’s just the patience of waiting it out. But what’s really exciting about that time frame is you’re buying a point, a point and a half, depending up to two points higher than market cap.
And you’re enjoying an incredible yield while you wait for that expiration. And if we look at today’s environment, people are looking for yield. I can put a fixed rate debt on an asset and on top of it, because there’s a limited number of these assets out there. And if you think about the rent being, say, 30% below market, you’re basically paying what would be to live in a 1970s or 1980s rent amount, but you get to live in a 2005 asset. So when the rest of the market is dealing with concessions and occupancy, these on average are 96% to 98% occupied. And on top of it, you’re only looking at about 25% or less of normal turnover
Because there’s fewer of these assets. So where a resident will move to, there’s a lot, there just tend to be longer term residents because you have less product available. It’s a privilege to get to kind of pay that amount and live in a vintage 30 years newer.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, no, that’s a great point. I’d be curious to know, you know, kind of back to one of the original points you made about the traditional multifamily space. There’s lots of markets that a lot of new supply came online in the last couple of years. You know, maybe some keep it saying oversupply in certain markets to where now in order to lease up, you’ve got to either reduce rents from what was originally pro forma, give different concessions in order to get these Talk to me about the balancing act when you’re looking at a LIHTC deal that might be in one of those markets to where maybe traditional market rate apartments now have come down enough to where there’s not that same delta that might have existed between LIHTC and market rate that might have existed maybe five years ago.
Is that a concern?
Janet LePage: So that is one of your buy box check marks, right? Your thesis has to show that market rent to what, you know, what your current rent is has to have that delta. What’s attractive about it right now is if you think the last four years you’ve seen markets where rents have dropped 30 percent. So if people were using this strategy four years ago. They could actually be very real in a position of an asset we wouldn’t buy. It loses its attractiveness if those rents don’t have that delta. That’s a critical buy box check. So when you’re saying, you know, when we’re looking at asset, you know, deals that come across our desk, the first one is what is the delta to market?
And right now, where are we at? You know, we’re seeing maybe in some markets you see some slight rent decline, flat, flat, some growth, some more forward growth, where, you know, even if rents drop one or two percent or even three or four percent, if you have a 30 percent delta today, because much of what we’re saying is rents are at the bottom. Right. So as long as you believe that to be true, even if they drop a little bit, you still have a material delta. Yeah. But yes, if you went back and somebody was using the C thesis in 2022 at the peak of market rents and now you’ve seen them drop, that delta could have gone away.
And that has occurred in some markets. But where we’re buying now, when we chose to enter this as a full focus sort of acquisition strategy, it was at a time where, you know, you’re not seeing that material rent drop. So your deltas, you know, are a lot more accurate.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, no, valid point. I love, let’s stay on the buy box discussion and topic. So maybe a couple other points that, you know, some of the big relevant points that you look for in the buy box, like maybe your property, vintage and condition, unit count. I know that we’ve talked about that. These are typically smaller in size than your traditional market rate apartment deals. You know, different types of geographic targets that you’re either focusing or staying away from. Maybe just give us a higher, you know, high level overview of what the rest of the buy box looks like.
Janet LePage: Okay, so first and foremost, the delta matters. Number two is how easy is it or how incented currently is that municipality or that state, that area of buying a building new LIHTC assets, right? So you want a lack of supply. That’s not unique to what we’re doing here. But if, you know, if you have limited competition, right? In a given geographic area, that’s going to keep your occupancy high. So really understanding some areas make it easier. They have more incentives to build. And that could be new construction, but we’re less concerned about new construction now as you were before. But even just new LIHTC is a really important piece to understand.
So that’s just a supply of competition. And that will directly relate to, you know, your occupancy. Uh, obviously, how is it operating? I look at it as more as an opportunity. Much of this is similar to even just any market rate deal. What’s interesting is because the developer, the way that really the original developer makes their money and the original investment partner is on the credits and the development fees that occurred 25 years ago. Let’s call it if you’re buying that at the original first 10 years of the development. And so if they’re in the business of continuing to make their own profits, their focus on operations might not be a primary because really all they’re making on that future side as you march along is just management fee, you know, just basic fees.
They really made their big profit. And so if you’re going to focus your teammates or your company somewhere, they’re going to focus on the next development.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah. Yeah. So they get their developer fee, they sell the tax credits, and then probably off to the next one, right? Hey, let’s set this and forget it. You know, let the PM company handle it. But really, their focus isn’t on maybe providing the best operations or oversight. It’s on to the next deal so they can make their next big pop.
Janet LePage: So there’s definitely, you know, as we’re looking through just your classic low hanging fruit, have you maximized the rent to the maximum allowable rent? That’s a very common one. On average, there’s been a historical increase in rent allowance of about 5%. And so you can walk into an asset that’s not even at maximum allowable rents. and still have that delta, you know, expense reduction. We have technology. We have a number of ways to just be innovative nowadays. And again, if your eye is not on your operations, we all know that’s like a number one place to check is like, can I operate this better than the current, you know, than the current operator?
So those, again, are, you know, key checkpoints. The other one, as you mentioned, is these do tend to be smaller buildings, generally speaking. The assets that we just closed, they’re about a half a mile apart and there’s two of them. So having them bundle is almost like operating a single larger one. You get the economies of scale in, you know, in the expense management, et cetera. So those are also things that you sort of check and get more, you know, excited about because you can have, you know, more than one asset near each other to, you know, share in the expenses.
Kevin Bupp: Why are these typically smaller in size? I mean, is there a reason for that?
Janet LePage: Well, a part of it is that, you know, if you go back, there are credits that are handed out and people, you know, they apply, you know, they apply to get those credits. And it’s just really the ratio that makes sense as they’re trying to hand out as many different credits. Living opportunities, right, so that people can live near where they work or whatnot. If a certain state only has so many credits, it does make sense that they would want to have them divided out into the certain municipalities so that they’re balancing where those tax credit housing can be.
Kevin Bupp: Understood. Understood. Okay. And how about vintage and age? Is there a certain floor that you have as far as how old a property is?
Janet LePage: I mean, I laugh when people ask. I mean, I’ve almost bought, what, 25,000 probably over almost 29 or 30,000 units or 1980. So when people go, so how do you feel about the CapEx in your 2010 asset or your, you know, 2005? And I laugh. I’m like, oh, my gosh, that’s my dream, right? So, yeah. The vintage, I mean, there will be, there can be deferred capital just like anything else, depending on what that is. That just has to be part of your budget. What you need when you’re buying these, if it’s not new, it doesn’t matter what the age is, you better have a really good construction team on your hands.
You know, our construction team, in my opinion, is, you know, one of the best. So… It doesn’t scare me that I have to replace a roof or fix something. It just means you better know what it’s going to cost. And you plan for that accordingly, right? That’s all. That is where people really miss is they don’t have that expertise on their team. They don’t, you know, they’re relying on a quote from someone else or something. That’s a big risk in anything. But I would chant that all the way back to older vintages of any kind is, you know, that matters. Your capex matters. Yeah.
Kevin Bupp: And congratulations on the recent closings. I believe those are the ones that we chatted about. If I can recall, they were in the Chattanooga MSA, correct?
Janet LePage: Yep.
Kevin Bupp: All right. I’m going to speak. Well, I love real examples. I know we kind of just touched on it a little bit. We kind of teased folks last show. But maybe walk us through these two problems. Now that they’re closed, I’m assuming that you can maybe talk a little bit more openly about them, if you can. But we’d love to know. Yeah, of course. Kind of year-built, unit count. you know, what the going in price was per unit. You can, we can talk about cap rate as well. And just maybe the, maybe expand upon the business model a little bit. And again, using these as a real example.
Janet LePage: So what we paid was a… I’m just going to round the numbers just for this, but you’re looking at about $115,000 a unit, okay? These are 2005 to 2010 vintage. Market rate for these exact same things. I’m talking right next door. If they were market rate, they would be $190 a door. And new construction, about $220 a door. So if you just take a step back… we’re, you know, we’re buying something $100,000 below new construction and basically $65,000 below the building right next door that if it didn’t, you know, if it had expired and was able to just do market rent, we don’t have to increase the rent, we don’t have to do anything else.
You’re buying the exact same unit. So when you’re talking about a basis value play, Now, the reason that you’re paying less for it is twofold. One of them is the rents are lower. So you just have that inherent alignment between cap rate of it. And the second piece is that you generally tend to have a smaller buyer pool. So you do get a premium. We obviously need to wait the five years for it to expire, right? So you can’t just go and sell it tomorrow. You can, but you need to wait for the… the rent LIHTC to expire. And I want to make something really clear there.
Often there’s programs that are offered by, you know, the municipality to make it attractive to keep it as a low-income tax credit housing, which is another alternative and something that is, you know, an exciting option. Yeah. If it doesn’t work, if that’s not available, then the expiring, you know, LIHTC, that means, what does it mean? You’re moving those rents to market and you’re comping something right next door. There’s no real secret. I’m not trying to make the building better. You know, when you do value add and I even see it right now with some people and I go, I don’t know why you’re thinking that.
Because let me tell you, I own enough units that we’re not getting it. But they sort of perform it. If I do A, B, and C, I get this. With this, it’s very basic. We don’t need to do anything more. We just don’t have to have the restriction on the asset.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah. I put myself in this example here. Again, congrats on it. Chattanooga is a great market. I put myself in the seller’s shoes, right? And I don’t know how long the prior ownership group held it for, but you’re getting to the end of the restriction timeline, right? And one would, Me in the same shoes, and I don’t know their situation, right? There’s a litany of reasons why they decided to sell when they sold, but just hold for another five years and ultimately run the same business plan. Any idea why they chose to sell so close to the expiration?
Janet LePage: So it’s not, I mean, it can be close or it can’t be. So what happens is there’s your first 15 years. So there’s always almost more than one block. So the first 15 years, in the first 10, you’re claiming the tax credits. In the last five of that, it says if you break any rules around renting improperly to the wrong people, you will be fined. So those first 15 years are really important. Okay. What is on that agreement from day one, though, is that you will pass the point where if you do it wrong, you’ll, you know, basically you lose your credits, which is really serious, is you will continue to do this for the next 15.
So the strategy of that, what I call the in-between. So once they hit the 15 years, many of those developers or they can sell or they do a renovation and do add more credits or some type of a benefit. So they’re in it for usually that next five or 10 years. They’ve gotten their next round of fees. They’ve already made their money, Kevin, you know, in a world. And we all know we all have investment partners that have a horizon. But if you think back to… If there’s five years left, they’ve already owned it or could have been involved in it for 25 or they could have been involved in it for the last 10.
And at that point, it’s just a different return model. So, I mean, it’s the same way that people always go, why did you guys sell when you did? Well, my business plan was done. And holding five more years is another round of cash.
Kevin Bupp: Fair enough. There’s always a reason. Understood. Understood. Did things incorrectly? You know, wasn’t fully in compliance? Or does the puck stop with them?
Janet LePage: So there’s sort of, to really sell your asset, to be able to sell it, you need to be in compliance for the most part. And it’s really important. What happens when you also say, how come person 123 couldn’t buy this asset? They bid on it. If you’ve broken rules of any kind and been sort of caught by the state or even if you weren’t intentionally doing it, they don’t allow you. The approval for me to buy isn’t just the seller selling. There’s other approvals depending on the asset. It could be the housing authority is part of the approval. Right. We believe that they are going to be fiduciaries and diligent to do this properly.
So your track record in this is really important. It’s a reference check. So that’s a piece. The second one is there can be fines for lack of compliance, especially in those first 15 years is even more critical. But yeah. When you’re doing your due diligence, again, people get scared off because it’s not just the due diligence of what’s my cat-backs, you know, how are the residents, blah, blah, blah. You have these other things that you have to adhere to and you need to make sure you’re buying an asset that’s in compliance or if it somehow was missed, now it’s your problem to fix.
Kevin Bupp: What expertise needs to be involved in your team? Is this a specialized legal team that needs to be involved in understanding the complexities around the restrictions and the documents that mandate those restrictions? I’d like to understand, maybe not go super deep and granular, but the additional complexities outside of a traditional due diligence on a market rate apartment and how much of a deeper dive needs to be done here. And what are some of the big gotchas?
Janet LePage: So reviewing all of the documents, especially when expiry is occurring and what you have to follow during expiry. So before I go into that, let’s just talk about your team. You know, you have in-house and what I call out-of-house expertise. You definitely have on your legal team, if you will, during due diligence, expertise in this for sure. Okay. The other piece is the local housing authority plays a big role. Whether it’s called, it’s different in every municipality, but who is sort of governing this and checking, you know, checking that you’re in compliance. Having someone on your team that has real experience, not just in compliance, but actually in that local area is important.
So many of them aren’t going to be in-house. a consultants, if you will, and how well they do that matters. There’s a lot of groups out there that say, I can be your, you know, we can be your consulting part and not do a good job. So that’s a good gotcha. If you think, if you don’t understand enough and you think that this consulting group is going to do a good job and they don’t, that’s a problem. So being involved in this from that perspective is really, you know, is really important. And then in-house, You need someone to know enough to be dangerous. How about that?
I always say, how much do I need to know intimately and how much do I need to know to know that my team of experts isn’t missing anything? And that’s truthfully that just comes with experience and time.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah. Yeah. I’m assuming that you’ve looked at a lot of potential opportunities, maybe one that looked attractive financially from the outside looking in, but then maybe it became less appealing when you understood maybe some of the nuance associated with those specific compliance requirements. Is there any deals like that that come to mind? And if so, okay, yeah, what were some of the things that were uncovered that said, hey, I would love this. I love this market. It looks great from the outside in, but this is a no-go.
Janet LePage: So in the expiry, it could be as simple as here’s the date. And basically after that date, as you renew leases, you can move them to market rate. Some of those documents will say it’s a three-year period past expiration. So suddenly your five-year timeline goes to an eight-year timeline potentially or longer depending on what that is. There can be things like first right of sale. to a group that will put new credits or do something in there. And it’s, you know, it doesn’t necessarily have to match price. That’s a big one, right? That’s a, you know, that’s huge. So there, that’s where the, like, the, like the small print is not identical.
You know, if you have a Freddie Mac loan. Those loan docs are pretty much the same form, right? You read one, you read them all. These documents are not like that. One doesn’t match the next because it was a negotiation at the time of construction 25 years ago with that municipality on why they were going to, or that state, if you will, Give those credits to that developer that, you know, they’re giving them out to create housing that they want to have for a long time. So they’re obviously advocating for the best interest. And so what the developer would agree to can make that more attractive.
Kevin Bupp: If the developer is going to make the majority of their money on the development fee and the tax credits, my gut would tell me that they would probably be pretty amenable to a lot of…
Janet LePage: Pretty generous. Yeah. Because they’re agreeing to something that’s 30 years from now and they’ve got nothing to do with it.
Kevin Bupp: Exactly. That’s interesting. Are there a lot of… Have you seen a lot that, again, outside looking, they look great, but they’ve got that more complexity to the language that just are immediate turnoff?
Janet LePage: So language doesn’t scare me anymore. You know, I think it would scare you if you don’t know what you’re doing. Hence, why won’t people step into this? Because it makes great sense. So we’re talking about an asset I’m talking about today that’s, you know, 2005 to 2010 at, you know, 100 grand below $100. you know, replacement costs, a 60 grand below, you know, 40% basically below what you have the next door. If it wasn’t intimidating to understand those documents, there would be a lot more people in this.
Kevin Bupp: Fair enough.
Janet LePage: Right? Yeah. So it is intimidating because, you know, it’s language that if you’re not in this as a, you know, and hence why you do want your inward, you know, your internal and external kind of partners that live and breathe this language. It’s a… It’s a way of being that you need to be sure you have the right expertise. Then it’s not scary. Then it’s just documents, right?
Kevin Bupp: How about something on the property management side? Obviously, again, correct me if I’m wrong, but it would seem to me that there’s some probably specialties that are needed or some experience, a specific experience that’s necessary from a property management team that might not be the same as that with just running a traditional market rate apartment complex. And so – On the operations front, obviously your internal, I think, I believe that you’re vertically integrated with your property management. So do you manage these in-house? And then second to that, do you have a kind of a specialized team on the PM side or specialized training that they must undergo or things they have to understand that your traditional PM at a normal apartment complex wouldn’t necessarily have to?
Janet LePage: So in this particular asset, one of our strategies is we don’t right at the beginning. What we do is we bring in a property management company that has very specific expertise in that city with that housing authority because that is such an incredibly important relationship. So what happens in many of these is before you lease the next unit, although you’ve done the paperwork, they have to come out. View the unit, the housing authority, and approve that it’s to a certain level of occupancy, so to a certain level of renovation and everything. So imagine this can be very slow. Now, if you have that relationship and you build that system where…
you know, they’re continuing to come out and it’s always good. Next thing you know, they’re like, just send us photos. Because as long as you’re consistent. And so that relationship is so important. And especially because it would be one thing if you were buying them all in Phoenix, but you’re not. You’re buying them in these different areas that have a different relationship. And so why do I say in the short term, our strategy is in the short term, you bring the experts in that are very local to that. Now, of course, we have obviously because we’re vertically integrated, we’re basically managing alongside, right, of that piece.
And once we have that rhythm and system, then we would consider bringing it in-house. But your risks of not, this is a very local operating type of concept, at least at the beginning. Without question.
Kevin Bupp: That makes sense. Based on a couple of those additional steps you mentioned there that’s required, like sometimes they’ve got to come take photos of the unit before it gets occupied. I can imagine that the leasing process then is quite a bit slower.
Janet LePage: It is.
Kevin Bupp: Given the additional steps that one has to jump through.
Janet LePage: Yeah. Now, what you can do, though, and of course, in innovation and creativity is because there’s not a lot of units, you have a wait list. You’ve already done all the qualification of a number of, you know, future residents that are really waiting to get in. So it’s in the innovation of how you operate that. It’s a little bit different than the traditional way. Once a resident lives there. It’s very much how do you operate a property. But that is where we still find a lot of efficiencies because what has happened is they focus solely on kind of an expert and maybe the compliance. That doesn’t mean they’re an expert in operating well in this day and age.
So it’s about marrying the two.
Kevin Bupp: Are there any additional protections in place with the residents that are under these LIHTC units as it relates to evictions? They still have to pay their rent just like a normal tenant would. Are there any additional protections that exist in the event they don’t pay rent?
Janet LePage: Uh, the answer is it depends. So again, when you’re doing your due diligence, just like it depends on if you’re buying in California versus, you know, Phoenix where there’s rent control or not. How many days are you allowed before you can, you know, file for eviction? That is state or municipality part of the DD. But generally speaking, if I just, if so… Other than those rules, no, there’s not a preferential. And because there’s a lack, again, it goes back to that there’s not a lot of other options to live in usually the surrounding area. So, yeah. You’re you’re fine. You find that you have a lot more long term tenants, that it’s a privilege to live there because, again, they’re paying about the same rent as something that, you know, is about 30 years newer and vintage for the same amount of rent.
So that discount is a privilege. And if you know, if they are evicted of some kind, you know. You know, that goes on their record and, you know, it’s just detailed a lot more, but it’s not so much going on their record as it is. There’s not another place they get really nearby that’s going to be able to do that. And they’re highly occupied. So there’s often a waiting list.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, no, that’s great. That’s great. And you mentioned agency debt. Fannie and Freddie are actively involved on the lending side of this space. And I believe from our first conversation, you said there’s even some additional benefits as it relates to maybe lower rates and slightly better terms than that of what would exist with market rate lending.
Janet LePage: Yeah. You know, it’s about it depends on the asset, but, you know, can be up to a quarter point or so, which matters. The other thing is that they can be flexible on the prepayment penalty that they’ll align it to the expiry. So, you know, in a traditional way, you get five years fixed, 10 years fixed. But what if it’s six years? That’s really when that expires. So they work with you to kind of modify that, which they don’t do in market rate, to help so that you would continue to operate it. And then that would weave off as market rate would come into play.
So like it’s, you know, it’s a government funded, right? So this is like anywhere they can kind of help. It’s, you know, it’s a whole department of benefits that can come of it.
Kevin Bupp: Has your group considered actually developing new property, new LIHTC properties? Ah. You know, I did the whole, obviously, the whole model and the thesis. It’s got to be part of the conversation, I would assume.
Janet LePage: I know, but I am a, no, the answer is no. I’m not a developer. We’re not developers. Could we develop? Sure. I think where people go amiss in, you know, in their investment strategies, there’s a lot of ways to make money in real estate, but you need to stay focused on what you can do well, what you know. niche market where the expertise is, that’s years in the making. Many of the developers, they’ve developed in that state a number of times. They know exactly how to get to the head of the line to get the credits. Could we do it? Sure. But you’re going to invest a lot of time in education before you started.
That is, I mean, as a number one lesson I’ve learned, keep myself focused in my lane that I’m good at.
Kevin Bupp: That’s right. No shiny objects.
Janet LePage: No shiny objects.
Kevin Bupp: We’d love to chat with you, Janet, about the coming years in scale. I think we talked about this a little bit before we hopped on here and really where you see the opportunity over these years, your growth goals. Call it looking three years out from now. We hope to have acquired X number of unit X number of light tech units or X number of light tech buildings. What does that look like, you know, in the coming years?
Janet LePage: You know, we’ve said that we would want this to be a pillar of somewhere, you know, three to five thousand units. That’s a big goal in this area. It’s a big goal because there just tend to be smaller, you know, smaller number of properties that make sense. Basically, my mandate was we buy as many as we can that fit the buy box. That’s the answer. It’s not a lack of equity to deploy them. It’s making sure that you’re very diligent in your buy box. What does make it attractive right now is that you are getting the volume, right? So if historically there’s only about 10,000 units a year that expire and now you’re at 60 or 70,000 a year, that’s a lot more volume to be able to sift through to make your thesis work.
Right. So it’s a lot of looking. It’s funny that you ask kind of what’s my number. The mandate is different right now. The mandate is find it, find the buy box, and the money’s there versus some big, huge cannon going off. It’s not a big, huge cannon going off kind of time in the market. It’s being prudent and making sure that you’re buying exactly with no hope of any more positive coming, right? So it’s, I’d say the mandate is different. It feels good too. If you can buy this, offer a great place to live in hopes that you can even extend those credits that make sense for the investment partner, that’s exciting.
That feels good.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, no, I agree. I agree. Given this kind of concentration of explorations that are coming down the pike, what do you see as the true window of opportunity? How long is this runway in your opinion?
Janet LePage: Next five years. There’s a lot coming in the next five years where, you know, the closer, like you said, the closer you get to market expiration, the more people that are offering and suddenly it doesn’t make business sense. As people just bid them up to basically, you know, a classic value add, as many people would do, is almost paying what the future value would be once you did all the work. Because that’s just a feeding frenzy. So you need to, you want to pick a far enough back expiry that, you know, you have a limited number of people that less number that are going to look at it from that perspective.
There’s that balancing act of where you purchase.
Kevin Bupp: Are there any geographic regions that you guys just absolutely steer clear of?
Janet LePage: There is areas where, you know, there’s a lot more focus on the affordable housing. And, you know, could there be risks of them changing the mandate, i.e. they’re not going to allow you to expire the credits or they’re going to put another mandate. So you do just like when you’re buying multifamily, you know, you if you’re if you’re an owner that doesn’t operate or doesn’t buy under a thesis of rent control, Don’t go into a state that you think there’s going to be rent control.
Kevin Bupp: That’s interesting. You know, I didn’t think of that regulatory risk. You know, even though it was written that, you know, ultimately this would expire at, you know, so-and-so date, they could change the rules entirely on you, which is ultimately similar to that of rent control legislation come down the pike, right? Just changing the rules and you having, as an owner, no control over what the outcome is.
Janet LePage: Right. That would be big. I mean, they’re written into the document. So it would be a big statement for them to do something as that. But when you have states that are much more social focused, I think you have more risk of something you’re not sure is going to occur to occur. So it’s, you know, those are pieces that you want to understand very well.
Kevin Bupp: If an experienced operator in the traditional sense of multifamily was listening here and they had an interest in entering into this space, what’s the first capability or skill set that you would tell them to get good at or build upon?
Janet LePage: Understanding all the compliance and rules, because at the end of the day, after that, you’re just operating, you’re operating a multifamily asset. But the making sure you understand the relationship between, you know, the housing authority and the state municipality and everything. And it’s really a micro operation on that piece that is just critical to understand those rules. Other than that, after you get through those, which are not hard, it’s just understanding them, you’re just operating a property just like anything else.
Kevin Bupp: Got it. Now, that’s great. Jay, before we wrap it up here, is there anything else? I know we only have so much time, right? And I know we can go down many, many rabbit holes. And this could be a multi-series podcast, but we’re not going to do that here today. But is there anything else that comes top of mind about the strategy that we just haven’t covered that you feel is relevant and folks need to understand?
Janet LePage: We talked a lot about expiring, Kevin, but I’ll give you an example of an asset that, you know, where it has nine years left. OK, so you’re further along instead of that five, but you’re looking at a cap rate of seven and a half to eight percent to purchase. Yeah. And it’s just cranks cash. It starts at about seven and a half and gets up to 14. And really all you’re doing is operating it, right? And so for investment thesis where you love yield, this is it. So this could be 10 years, 11 years, 12 years remaining.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah, exactly. It doesn’t have to be, you know, five or less years or seven or less years.
Janet LePage: No, not at all. And the closer you get to that second round of 15, kind of after they’ve made their money, they follow the compliance. The closer you are to that, so long-term funds, evergreen funds, family offices that just really want cash. I mean, that’s another piece of our strategy that I, like, if you ask me, Jenna, what do you want to build, you know, and own a big pool of? This stuff. You know, it’s full. You get long-term residents. You know, you’re in vintage that’s 2010 or newer. And you’re just operating it. And those cash flow dividends are massive. They’re massive. So that’s – we didn’t talk as much about it.
But to me, that’s part of my personal portfolio. That’s cash flow.
Kevin Bupp: So you’re still looking at that stuff.
Janet LePage: I mean, like that’s part of it. Absolutely. Absolutely. It’s a bit different than what I shared with you. It’s a different buyer profile, right? It’s a different investment partner profile because this is a longer term hold, but the yield is really good.
Kevin Bupp: But even then, I guess, given that additional context about maybe properties that have a much longer term, it really is just a purely yield play, at least for the next nine, 10 years, right? Is the opportunity bigger than that of maybe your target of 5,000 units? Is it bigger? Does that open up the buy box quite a bit, or is it still fairly restricted?
Janet LePage: As far as as far as scalability, it’s just it’s just it’s still the same thing. You know, when you are only buying 100 units or depending on size, that’s a lot of transactions in the realistic part. I just think, you know, and we do have family office partners. That’s a really, really exciting thesis. That’s, you know, that’s important.
Kevin Bupp: Yeah. No, fantastic. Well, Janet, as always, this has been a great conversation. Really appreciate you coming back on. And again, this was, we kind of just touched on it last time around. I know we went a little deeper this time. It’s probably even deeper that we could go. But in any event, I really appreciate your knowledge and you being transparent and sharing what you guys are doing in the space. And I guess, you know, for listeners that want to learn a little bit more about your company, Western Wealth, where’s the best place to find you?
Janet LePage: Our website, westernwealthcapital.com. And thank you, Kevin, for having me again. Take care.
Kevin Bupp: It’s been an absolute pleasure. And yeah, to everyone listening, thanks again for joining us for another episode of the Real Estate Investing for Cashflow podcast. If you found this conversation with Janet valuable, please do subscribe to the show and you’ll share the episode with someone in your network that you feel would gain value from it. Until next week’s show, I’m wishing you strong deals and even stronger cashflow. Take care, guys.